The Best 5 Cup Coffee Maker 2024

Good things come in small packages, so if you’re looking for the best 5 cup coffee maker, be prepared to be amazed by the great coffee you’ll brew in a small coffee maker.

Whether you have a small space, want to use less energy or just enjoy coffee in smaller batches, the great news is you have plenty of choice when it comes to choosing a good five cup coffee maker.

In these best 5 cup coffee maker reviews, I take you through all the factors to consider when purchasing a small coffee pot. I also compare the top rated 5 cup coffee makers on the market so you can find the right coffee maker for your home and circumstances.

Top Picks

Don’t have time to read my complete best five cup coffee maker reviews and just want to hear my recommendations?

• Top pick – Mr Coffee Programmable Mini Brew
• Best thermal – Bonavita BV1500TS
• Best budget – Black+Decker coffeemaker

The Best 5 Cup Coffee Maker 2024 Comparison

Below is a handy table where you can see all the different options reviewed within this article. 

We review each of these machines in the reviews below.

Image	Name	Carafe Type	Capacity	Our Rating	Price
	Cuisinart 5570 Coffeemaker	Stainless Steel	25 oz / 4 cups	4.6	CHECK
	Mr. Coffee Programmable Mini Coffee Maker	Glass	25 oz / 5 cups	5.0	CHECK
	Capresso Mini Coffeemaker	Glass	25 oz / 5 cups	4.8	CHECK
	Mr. Coffee Mini Brew coffee maker	Glass	25 oz / 5 cups	4.6	CHECK
	Black+Decker coffeemaker	Glass	25 oz / 5 cups	4.8	CHECK
	Bonavita One-Touch Coffee Brewer	Thermal	25 oz / 5 cups	5.0	CHECK
	Holstein Housewares red coffee maker	Glass	25 oz / 5 cups	4.4	CHECK
	Hamilton Beach Compact Coffee Pot	Glass	25 oz / 5 cups	4.4	CHECK
	Krups Simply Brew Coffee Maker	Glass	25 oz / 5 cups	4.6	CHECK

Why Purchase A 5 Cup Coffee Pot?

With so many large coffee makers on the market, why consider a small 5-cup coffee maker?

Well there are a range of reasons why a five cup coffee maker makes sense including:

• Small machines use less energy.
• 5 cup drip coffee makers use less coffee than large brewers (less waste).
• A small coffee pot takes up less space and can be packed away if needed.
• They are perfect for 1 or 2 coffee drinkers who enjoy a single cup of coffee.

Things To Consider When Purchasing The Best 5 Cup Drip Coffee Maker

To purchase a brewer that is ideal for your needs, consider the following factors. 

If you already know what you need, hop straight to the reviews here.

1. Cup Size

When it comes to filter coffee makers, know that a “cup” doesn’t equal your standard 8-12 ounce mug.  In fact there is no cup standard at all – with variation between each coffee maker brand.

Buyers are often caught out when buying small coffee makers as they assume a cup refers to a mug.

Usually, a coffee maker cup is defined as just 5 ounces, which is about half the size of a regular mug of coffee!

So if these coffee makers are too small, consider a larger capacity model such as quality coffee makers like these.

2. Coffee Maker Size

Naturally a five five cup coffee maker will be pretty compact. But still double check the overall dimensions of the machine before purchasing. 

Check the width and depth of the machine’s base as well as the height to ensure it will fit on your countertop and under any overhead cabinets.

Also check if the water reservoir needs to be filled from the top or the side as this may affect where you can position the brewer.

3. Carafe Material

Most coffee maker carafes or either glass or stainless steel. They all have their pros and cons:

• Stainless steel is more durable.  Some stainless steel carafes are also thermal carafes to keep your coffee warm for longer.
• Glass is the traditional material.  They are easy to clean and don’t absorb flavors, but are more fragile.

4. Filter

Coffee maker filters are either stainless steel or plastic and some require paper filters.

Reusable steel filters are more environmentally friendly and convenient as you don’t need to stock paper filters. However they can result in more grit in the base of your carafe.

If you prefer brewing coffee through paper filters, you can still use these with a reusable coffee filter.

5. Settings

Like any appliance, the best rated 5 cup coffee makers come with a range of settings.  Here are a few settings worth considering:

• Programmable Timer: A 5 cup programmable coffee maker means you can wake up to freshly brewed coffee.

• Keep Warm Function:  If you’re not buying a 5 cup coffee maker with thermal carafe, then you’ll want to ensure it has a keep warm function.  Check how long it will keep coffee warm for.

• Brew Pause:  The brew pause feature allows you to sneak a cup of coffee mid brew.

• Auto Shut Down:  A 5 cup coffee maker with auto shut off will shut down after a certain period of non use.

6. Cleaning

Most coffee makers are pretty simple to clean – but it is worth checking whether the removable parts, such as the carafe and filter (if the machine has one), are dishwasher safe.

The Best 5 Cup Coffee Maker Reviews 2024

1. Cuisinart 5-Cup Coffee Maker Review

The Cuisinart DC 5570 is a relative newcomer to the small coffee pot line-up and similar to their 4 cup model.

With this stylish compact coffee machine, you’ll have great tasting coffee in minutes.

The Cuisinart 5 cup coffee pot features a durable stainless steel carafe and 30 minute keep warm feature. Other features include:

• Brew pause feature
• Removable water reservoir
• Charcoal water filter
• Permanent nylon coffee filter

The removable water tank makes it really easy to fill no matter what your style of kitchen and the small design means it easily fits on most countertops.

It is also a high powered unit with 1100 watts and comes with a long 3 year limited warranty, more than most on this list.

If you’re looking for an affordable small coffee maker with stainless steel carafe, this Cuisinart is a great option.

>> Click here to shop the Cuisinart on Amazon

2. Mr. Coffee Programmable Coffee Maker Review

Best 5 cup programmable coffee maker

For those who love the smell of freshly brewed coffee when they wake up, the new Mr Coffee Programmable coffee brewer is a must buy. 

We think this is the best small programmable coffee maker option – perfect for 1 or 2 people to enjoy a cup of coffee first thing in the morning.

The new version has a sleeker, more modern design, and an improved water dispensing arm for better tasting coffee.

The programmable setting is one of the best features of this Mr Coffee 5 cups coffee maker.  Simply program it the night before, and there is no need to wait around for it to brew in the morning. 

However if you forget to do this, the sneak a cup function is a lifesaver, as you won’t need to wait for the brewing cycle to complete before you can grab a cuppa.

Other features of the Mr. Coffee Mini Brew include:

• A water filtration disk for better tasting coffee
• Dishwasher safe nylon filter basket
• 2 hour auto shut off
• Ergonomic handle
• Easy to read markings and a water window so you’ll know when it’s time to refill the reservoir.

For the price, this is a great little coffee brewer with a ton of features. It is so compact that it will take up barely any space on your kitchen counter, in your RV or in your dorm and uses just 650 watts of power.

If you’re after the best 5 cup programmable coffee maker, do yourself a favor and check this one out.

>> Click here to shop the Mr Coffee on Amazon

3. Capresso Coffee Maker 5 Cup Review

This is one of the highest rated mini drip coffee makers and it isn’t hard to see why. 

The Capresso Mini Drip coffeemaker has all the features you need and makes great tasting coffee for even the fussiest coffee drinker.

One of the features that sets this machine apart from the others is the goldtone filter.  Not often seen on machines at this price point, this filter helps produce a better tasting coffee. 

It is also programmable so you can wake up to fresh coffee and there’s no need to wait! Other features include:

• Durable glass carafe
• Automatic 2 hour keep warm function
• Top fill water tank. 

Unfortunately there is no water window but it does come with a one year warranty and runs at 650 watts.

For coffee drinkers looking for a highly rated 5 cup coffee maker, the Capresso is one of the best options thanks to the wide range of features and programmability.

>> Click here to shop the Capresso on Amazon

4. Mr Coffee Mini Brew Coffee Maker Review

The Mini Brew is a great affordable option.  This drip coffee maker is similar to the Mr Coffee reviewed above but with fewer features and a lower price tag.

The main difference is this 5 cup Mr Coffee maker does not feature the programmable setting, with just a simple on/off switch. 

It does feature the handy grab a cup auto pause function, so you won’t need to wait for the brewing cycle to complete before you can sneak a cup. It uses basket style paper filters, or you can purchase a compatible permanent filter separately.

Other features include:

• A removable filter basket for simple filling and cleaning
• Warming plate to keep coffee warm
• Dual water window to make filling the reservoir easy and mess free.  
• 650 watt brewer comes with a one year warranty.

Despite the small number of features, it is one of the top rated small coffee makers on Amazon.

It is a super cute looking compact coffee machine that is easy to use and super cheap.  Perfect for small apartments, occasional coffee drinkers or college students in dorms.

>> Click here to shop the Mr Coffee Mini Brew on Amazon

5. Black and Decker 5 Cup CoffeeMaker Review

Best cheap 5 cup coffee maker

If you’re just after a great budget option that gets the job done, the Black and Decker 5 Cup Coffee Brewer CM0700BZ is one to consider. 

With a flick of the switch, this machine will have you drinking freshly brewed coffee in next to no time. Features include:

• A durable glass carafe with ergonomic handle and drip free pouring
• Permanent filter basket
• On/off switch
• Sneak a cup feature

The permanent filter basket means you won’t need to spend extra on disposable paper filters.

Note this Black and Decker small coffeemaker doesn’t have an auto-off switch and is not programmable.

However despite being a cheap option, this brewer does have the sneak a cup feature, which is brilliant when you’re in a rush. 

Other great features include the easy view water window, a hot plate to keep your coffee warm, plus all removable parts are dishwasher safe.

It also comes with a two year warranty, which is more than most on our list.

If you’re after one of the best five cup coffee makers yet don’t have a big budget, you’ll be pleasantly surprised with the features of this cheap Black and Decker coffee maker.

>> Click here to shop the Black and Decker on Amazon

6. Bonavita 5 Cup Drip Coffee Maker BV1500TS Review

Best certified 5 cup coffeemaker

If you are looking for the best tasting coffee and want a small coffee machine capable of brewing coffee fast, then the Bonavita BV1500TS coffee maker is certainly one to consider. 

This is a top of the range 5 cup coffee brewer capable of making great tasting coffee at the touch of a button and is SCAA certified to make consistently great coffee.

Unlike cheaper machines, throughout the brewing process, this Bonavita 5-cup coffee maker maintains a steady shower of water, which is consistently heated to the optimal temperature of around 200-203 F to ensure the very best extraction of flavor. 

This best 5 cup drip coffee maker also comes with an optional pre infusion mode, which is great for maximizing coffee ground flavor and aroma extraction.

It doesn’t include a heating plate as it has a stainless steel lined thermal carafe. Your coffee is maintained at the optimal temperature once it’s brewed for around one hour.

The brew basket uses #4 cone shaped filters and you can even brew as little as 3 cups (15 oz) at a time. Other features include:

• Fast 5 minute brew time
• High powered 1100w heater
• Pre-infusion mode
• Dishwasher safe parts including the carafe lid, filter basket and showerhead.

Note if you want a 5 cup thermal coffee maker, but also need the option to brew a larger pot when you have company, Bonavita make this brewer in an 8 cup size too.

The larger brewer can brew as little as 2 cups or 8 cups at a time. Something to consider for more flexibility. You can see the 8 cup maker here.

For coffee lovers looking for a high quality, small and compact coffee machine, this 5 cup coffee maker with auto shut off is one of the best Bonavita models to consider. 

It is one of the more expensive machines in these reviews, but it comes from a highly reputable coffee maker brand. Plus with a generous 2 year warranty included, we think the investment is well worth it.

>> Click here to shop the Bonavita on Amazon

7. Holstein Housewares 5-Cup Coffee Maker Review

If you need some color in your life, the Holstein Housewares drip coffee maker is the perfect choice! Coming in a range of bright colors including red, mint, yellow and teal, this machine will certainly brighten up your kitchen.

The Holstein 5 cup drip machine not only looks great but provides all the basic features you need for great tasting coffee fast.

It is an easy to use coffee machine featuring a glass carafe and a warming plate to keep your coffee hot plus: 

• Removable, reusable cone filter basket
• Brew pause feature
• Reusable scooper
• Water level window which helps you fill the reservoir with ease.

This 650 watt 5 cup red coffee maker is not packed with settings and features.

There is no automatic shut off and it is not programmable. But it has all you need to make freshly brewed coffee fast and comes at a great price. 

Plus with a bright colored design, the Holstein is perfect for those wanting something a little different on their kitchen bench.

>> Click here to shop the Holstein on Amazon

8. Hamilton Beach 5-Cup Coffee Pot Review

Hamilton Beach is well known for making top quality coffee makers, so it’s no surprise that they feature in this 5 cup coffee maker review guide. 

This brewer from Hamilton Beach is a great inexpensive no fuss option with some unique extras.

This Hamilton Beach machine is the only smart plug compatible coffee maker featured on our list – while it doesn’t have auto shut off built in, you can program it with your plug.

Use voice commands with Alexa, Google Home or Siri to make coffee making even simpler. Other features include:

• A glass dishwasher safe carafe
• Swing away filter basket for easy front filling
• Nonstick hot plate that keeps your coffee warm.

Like all great coffee machines, the Hamilton Beach small coffee maker has the brew pause, which enables you to grab a cuppa before the brewing process is complete.  It is also easy to wipe down and keep clean.

Although for such a quality brand like Hamilton Beach, it’s disappointing it doesn’t have settings such as automatic shut off or a timer. It comes with a 1 year warranty.

For lovers of Hamilton Beach products looking for an easy to use, compact 5 cup coffee maker, this is a great option to consider.

>> Click here to shop the Hamilton Beach on Amazon

9. Krups Simply Brew 5 Cup Coffee Pot Review

The Krups Simply Brew coffee pot is a great option from a highly regarded coffee maker brand and one of the most popular brewers on our list.

It is a fast and compact coffee brewer, with a one hour keep warm function and easy to use no drip glass carafe. Features include:

• A simple one touch brew function
• Brew pause feature
• Permanent coffee filter
• No drip dishwasher safe glass carafe

It also comes with a two year warranty for peace of mind.

The water is filled from the top, so be sure you can fit it under any overhead cabinets when the lid is open.

The Simply brew coffee maker is an easy to use coffee machine and one of the best compact coffee maker models available. 

>> Click here to shop the Krups on Amazon

FAQs

How many cups does a 5 cup coffee maker make?

Most 5 cup coffee makers brew 25 ounces of coffee. However, a regular coffee mug holds between 8 – 12 ounces of coffee, so a 5 cup brewer will make 2 to 3 mugs of coffee.

How many spoons of coffee for a 5 cup coffee maker?

For a medium strength brew, it is recommended to use 1 coffee scoop or 2 tablespoons of coffee for every 5 ounces of water. However it is worth reading the instruction manual as they will often advise how many scoops of coffee are best for the machine.

Before You Go

We hope you found the right five cup drip coffee maker for your home in this guide. If you are still looking, check out our guide to RV coffee makers as they are also compact or our 4 cup coffee maker reviews.

If you’re ready to make great coffee, read our guide to the best coffee beans or discover how to brew a great tasting coffee here.

More Coffee Maker Guides

• Top rated SCAA certified coffee makers
• The best dual coffee makers
• Best automatic pour over coffee brewer

Or take a look at all our coffee maker reviews here.

Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.